The Japanese government is taking this way too far and totally agree with the author of this article that this is a bad bad thing. As I've said before, legislation during emotionally charged times often ends up being stupid and poorly thought through. The ramifications of such a law would be devastating for NGO's and aid workers from Japan, just when such activity is becoming recognized. It almost feels like some stupid conspiracy to use this incident to squash the NGO's in Japan. Bah. I have less and less respect for the Japanese government every day.The Japan TimesKidnap crisis poses a new riskIn Japan's case, laws are being proposed to punish those entering designated "danger zones" without an official reason.
Victims -- or their families -- will foot the bill for their rescue, which will amount to airfare, if not more. "This is standard practice for mountain rescues," one line of reasoning goes.
But consider two things: One is that an aid mission to a danger zone is not a forest stroll gone astray. The very comparison indicates a misunderstanding of what aid missions do.
The second is policy overstretch and political abuse. This law would place a degree of government control over aid organizations, something many don't want. Particularly NGOs (by very the nature of their title) eschew government support, especially when they take on problems governments would rather avoid.
Under this law, they would effectively need official permission to work in some places overseas. Those "unsponsored" who get unlucky will face a "rescue fine" -- which could bankrupt the person or the organization. Thus this new system of rents will curtail Japanese volunteerism.
Government trying to use hostage crisis to squash NGO's in Japan »
Joi
May 12, 2004 - 00:18 UTC »
Categories:
7 Comments
Leave a comment
Search
About this Archive
This page is an archive of recent entries in the Business and the Economy category.
Books is the previous category.
Computer and Network Risks is the next category.
Find recent content on the main index.
Recent Posts
- The Internet, innovation and learning
- Iron Blogger - Strike One
- You are the Power of Open: 2011 Creative Commons Annual Campaign
- Thoughts on leadership - IBM100 THINK Forum
- Designing systems for transparency robustness
- Safecast and CC0
- Getting my blog voice back
- Blogging
- LinkedIn Japan
- Joining the MIT Media Lab
Tag Cloud
Categories
- Activism (77)
- Advanced Science (9)
- Art (53)
- BitTorrent (1)
- Blogging about Blogging (501)
- Books (64)
- Business and the Economy (19)
- CPSR (4)
- Computer and Network Risks (26)
- Consumer Electronics (22)
- Cool Web Sites (81)
- Creative Commons (151)
- Dashboard (1)
- Eating and Cooking (40)
- Ecology (12)
- Economics (39)
- Email (18)
- Emergent Democracy (111)
- Energy (13)
- Flash (5)
- Gadgets (88)
- Games (35)
- Gender (10)
- Global Politics (113)
- Global Voices (39)
- Hardware (13)
- Health and Medicine (95)
- Heckling (46)
- Human Rights (19)
- Humor (164)
- ICANN (50)
- IM (2)
- IRC (47)
- Identity (15)
- Information and Media (60)
- Intellectual Property (124)
- Internet Policy (13)
- Introspective (79)
- Japanese Culture (123)
- Japanese National ID (29)
- Japanese Policy (97)
- Japanese Politics (50)
- Joi's Diary (656)
- Joicards (4)
- LOAF (15)
- Leadership and Entrepreneurship (21)
- Marketing (36)
- Media and Journalism (165)
- Moblogging (47)
- Movies (45)
- Mozilla (13)
- Music (103)
- Neoteny (20)
- Network Technology (51)
- Open Source Software (13)
- People (21)
- Photo (155)
- Podcasts (17)
- Privacy (104)
- Python Fun (18)
- Reforming Japanese Democracy (28)
- Religion (29)
- SARS (12)
- Salon (1)
- Search (51)
- Second Life (6)
- Sharing Economy (23)
- Six Apart (11)
- Social Software (116)
- Socialtext (5)
- Software (81)
- Technology Controversy (68)
- Technorati (26)
- US Policy and Politics (204)
- Venture Capital (17)
- Video (33)
- VoIP (12)
- Warblogging (101)
- Wiki (64)
- Wireless and Mobile (112)
- World of Warcraft (19)
Monthly Archives
- March 2013 (1)
- February 2013 (1)
- December 2012 (2)
- June 2012 (2)
- April 2012 (2)
- January 2012 (2)
- December 2011 (2)
- November 2011 (1)
- October 2011 (1)
- September 2011 (3)
- August 2011 (2)
- May 2011 (1)
- April 2011 (1)
- March 2011 (2)
- December 2010 (2)
- November 2010 (1)
- October 2010 (2)
- September 2010 (1)
- August 2010 (1)
- July 2010 (5)
- June 2010 (3)
- May 2010 (5)
- March 2010 (1)
- February 2010 (2)
- January 2010 (3)
- December 2009 (4)
- November 2009 (1)
- October 2009 (2)
- September 2009 (1)
- August 2009 (1)
- June 2009 (1)
- May 2009 (4)
- April 2009 (8)
- March 2009 (5)
- February 2009 (4)
- January 2009 (10)
- December 2008 (23)
- November 2008 (14)
- October 2008 (10)
- September 2008 (11)
- August 2008 (13)
- July 2008 (18)
- June 2008 (16)
- May 2008 (6)
- April 2008 (5)
- March 2008 (4)
- February 2008 (10)
- January 2008 (10)
- December 2007 (13)
- November 2007 (8)
- October 2007 (11)
- September 2007 (14)
- August 2007 (9)
- July 2007 (14)
- June 2007 (14)
- May 2007 (13)
- April 2007 (23)
- March 2007 (19)
- February 2007 (14)
- January 2007 (13)
- December 2006 (20)
- November 2006 (12)
- October 2006 (5)
- September 2006 (10)
- August 2006 (7)
- July 2006 (8)
- June 2006 (20)
- May 2006 (14)
- April 2006 (10)
- March 2006 (17)
- February 2006 (17)
- January 2006 (20)
- December 2005 (23)
- November 2005 (45)
- October 2005 (37)
- September 2005 (28)
- August 2005 (37)
- July 2005 (37)
- June 2005 (29)
- May 2005 (48)
- April 2005 (55)
- March 2005 (44)
- February 2005 (37)
- January 2005 (43)
- December 2004 (57)
- November 2004 (79)
- October 2004 (85)
- September 2004 (62)
- August 2004 (78)
- July 2004 (77)
- June 2004 (61)
- May 2004 (72)
- April 2004 (56)
- March 2004 (76)
- February 2004 (74)
- January 2004 (94)
- December 2003 (71)
- November 2003 (69)
- October 2003 (72)
- September 2003 (71)
- August 2003 (59)
- July 2003 (65)
- June 2003 (60)
- May 2003 (53)
- April 2003 (79)
- March 2003 (106)
- February 2003 (71)
- January 2003 (68)
- December 2002 (56)
- November 2002 (54)
- October 2002 (73)
- September 2002 (50)
- August 2002 (61)
- July 2002 (32)
- June 2002 (12)
- May 2002 (1)
- April 2002 (2)
- December 2001 (1)
- October 2001 (1)
- July 2001 (1)
- February 2001 (1)
- January 2001 (1)
- December 2000 (1)
- November 2000 (1)
- October 2000 (1)
- September 2000 (1)
- August 2000 (1)
- July 2000 (1)
- June 2000 (1)
- May 2000 (1)
- April 2000 (2)
- March 2000 (1)
- February 2000 (1)
- January 2000 (1)
- December 1999 (1)
- November 1999 (1)
- October 1999 (1)
- September 1999 (3)
- April 1999 (1)
- February 1999 (5)
- January 1999 (2)
- December 1998 (2)
- October 1998 (1)
- August 1998 (7)
- November 1997 (1)
- October 1997 (1)
- June 1997 (1)
- April 1997 (1)
- October 1996 (1)
- October 1995 (1)
- June 1995 (1)
- May 1995 (1)
- March 1995 (2)
- November 1994 (1)
- July 1993 (2)
![Joi Ito [logo]](/_site/img/joi-ito-logo-92x.png)



wow, so much for government taking care of it's citizens. What the assinine reasoning behind this?
Don't we in the US have similar plans to isolate cities in the event of a major crisis?
I heard on the news yesterday that the government is discussing jamming cell phone channels in the event of an actual or suspected terrorist incident.. the downside of this, they were saying, is that people 'couldn't call 911' - Nobody mentioned that if this was done that they also couldn't call their loved ones to let them know they were okay - or not - like they did on 9/11.
Those calls were absolutely important for many people.. to establish peace of mind, or in some cases, to say a tearful farewell to someone who was trapped in a imminently fatal situation.
This unreal willingness on the part of the government to impose an information blockade on dying people under the guise of stopping terrorism scares the crap out of me.
As an aside, apart from the US, where would you go if you decided to emigrate?
Humm,
I have mixed feelings about this. Most NGO's from Japan do not operate in Iraq, so the number of NGOs affected could be really low. In Iraq, there are terrorist groups that have declared publicly that all foreigners from coalition countries are fair targets for killing. I remember hearing about the Japanese volunteers going over there before the war began and shortly after and thinking "these people are really naive." Maybe they were, maybe not, but now I would not assume the same about someone heading to Iraq. Now I would have to say that they are extreme activists or are nutty. The risks are out there and known because of the Japanese hostage incident.
The government is saying that they will still rescue people but will charge them money. This really puts the responsibility on the individual/group who wants to go someplace dangerous. In a way it makes sense. Tell people not to go to a dangerous place and they still go, but tell them that they will have to pay for their rescue and perhaps they will reconsider.
Japanese people in Iraq are at great risk. I assume it is only a matter of time before something horrible happens to one of them. I hope that anyone who is there will consider returning to Japan.
I am sure that the government are not doing this the right way though. They will probably end up with some law that is too far reaching in its authority. They may end up using this as a way to force NGO's to represent government interests. So I can see why you do not like the idea.
> They will probably end up with some law that is
> too far reaching in its authority. They
> may end up using this as a way to force NGO's
> to represent government interests. So
> I can see why you do not like the idea.
For example, 'rescue' someone who doesn't need rescuing, and send them a legal bill greater than their annual income. Or just threaten to do so.
In any case, following the recent execution of the American man in Iraq (who was working on power or phone lines, and was honestly motivated by a desire to help), I think more people will be reconsidering whether they want to work in such charged environments.
It's hardly fair to say that he knew the risks, though. Nobody outside the military knew that the situation would collapse in the way it has following the discoveries of what has been going on inside prisons in Iraq.
hello Joe, I don't understand why the Japanese govt. had to initiate an attack on Iraqi for no reason at all by supporting the occupiers of Iraq?
Personally i believe that the Iraqi's are justified in attacking the foriegners helping the occupation.
I read that the Japanese hostages released by the Iraqi militia had been charged by the government for their flights home. I thought I'd misunderstood, or it was some strange accounting discrepency. It was some damned inflated figure, too.
I really don't think this is the best way for the Japanese government to get itself out of its debt hole....